Oppn walks out amid SIR debate, Shah says ‘But I said infiltrators should get out’
The Indian Parliament witnessed a dramatic scene yesterday as Opposition MPs staged a walkout during Home Minister Amit Shah’s address. The walkout was sparked by Shah’s comments on the issue of the National Register of Citizens (NRC) and the National Population Register (NPR), which have been at the center of a heated debate in the country. The Home Minister took a dig at the Opposition, saying that they raised the issue of the NRC and NPR to keep illegal immigrants in the voter lists. However, as the Opposition MPs walked out, Shah made a remark that left the rest of the Parliament members in stitches.
“But I said infiltrators should get out,” Shah said, amidst the din of the walkout, to which other members of the Parliament can be heard laughing. The comment was seen as a clever quip by the Home Minister, who has been under fire from the Opposition for his handling of the NRC and NPR issue. The walkout was a clear indication of the deep divisions within the Parliament on the issue, with the Opposition parties strongly opposing the government’s move to implement the NRC and NPR.
The debate on the NRC and NPR has been ongoing for several weeks, with the Opposition parties alleging that the government is trying to use these exercises to target minority communities, particularly Muslims. The government, on the other hand, has maintained that the NRC and NPR are necessary to identify and deport illegal immigrants who have entered the country. The issue has sparked widespread protests across the country, with many citizens expressing concerns about the potential impact on their lives and livelihoods.
The Home Minister’s comments yesterday were seen as an attempt to deflect the criticism and shift the focus away from the government’s handling of the issue. However, the Opposition parties were quick to respond, saying that Shah’s comments were an attempt to polarize the debate and distract from the real issues at hand. The walkout was a clear indication that the Opposition parties are not willing to back down on the issue and will continue to press the government for answers.
The NRC and NPR issue has been a contentious one, with many experts and activists raising concerns about the potential impact on marginalized communities. The NRC, which was first implemented in Assam, has been criticized for its flawed methodology and the potential for errors and exclusions. The NPR, which is scheduled to be conducted across the country, has also raised concerns about the collection of personal data and the potential for misuse.
The government has maintained that the NRC and NPR are necessary to ensure national security and prevent illegal immigration. However, the Opposition parties have argued that the exercises are unnecessary and will only serve to create more problems for citizens. The debate has sparked a wider discussion about the role of citizenship and identity in India, with many citizens questioning the need for such exercises.
As the debate continues, it is clear that the issue of the NRC and NPR will remain a contentious one in the coming weeks and months. The Opposition parties will continue to press the government for answers, while the government will likely maintain its stance on the issue. The walkout yesterday was just the latest indication of the deep divisions within the Parliament on the issue, and it remains to be seen how the situation will unfold in the coming days.
In the meantime, citizens across the country will be watching the developments closely, with many anxiously waiting to see how the issue will affect their lives and livelihoods. The NRC and NPR debate has sparked a wider discussion about the role of citizenship and identity in India, and it is clear that the issue will have far-reaching implications for the country.
As the Parliament continues to debate the issue, it is essential that the government listens to the concerns of citizens and Opposition parties. The NRC and NPR exercises must be conducted in a transparent and fair manner, with adequate safeguards to prevent errors and exclusions. The government must also ensure that the exercises do not target minority communities or create more problems for citizens.
In conclusion, the walkout by Opposition MPs during Home Minister Amit Shah’s address yesterday was a clear indication of the deep divisions within the Parliament on the issue of the NRC and NPR. The debate will continue to be a contentious one, with the Opposition parties pressing the government for answers and the government maintaining its stance on the issue. As the situation unfolds, it is essential that the government listens to the concerns of citizens and Opposition parties and conducts the NRC and NPR exercises in a transparent and fair manner.
News Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch
About the Author
