Judge who ordered FIR on ASP Anuj Chaudhary in Sambhal violence case transferred
In a significant development, Sambhal Chief Judicial Magistrate Vibhanshu Sudheer, who had ordered the registration of an FIR against ASP Anuj Chaudhary, inspector Anuj Tomar, and 20 unidentified police officials for their alleged role in the shooting of a youth during the 2024 Sambhal violence, has been transferred. The transfer order was issued on Tuesday, and Sudheer has now been appointed as the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Sultanpur.
The Sambhal violence case has been a highly contentious issue, with allegations of police brutality and excesses against the protesters. The incident had sparked widespread outrage, and the order to register an FIR against the police officials was seen as a significant step towards ensuring accountability.
However, the transfer of Sudheer has raised questions about the independence of the judiciary and the potential for interference in the functioning of the courts. The timing of the transfer, coming as it does after the order to register the FIR, has led to speculation about the reasons behind the move.
It is worth noting that Sudheer’s order to register the FIR was based on the findings of a magisterial inquiry, which had concluded that the police had indeed fired at the protesters, resulting in the injury of a youth. The inquiry had also recommended action against the police officials involved in the incident.
The transfer of Sudheer has been seen as a setback to the efforts to ensure justice for the victims of the Sambhal violence. The new Chief Judicial Magistrate, Aditya Singh, who has been appointed to replace Sudheer, will now have to oversee the further proceedings in the case. Singh had earlier ordered a survey of the Shahi Jama Masjid, which had sparked controversy and protests from the local community.
The Sambhal violence case has highlighted the challenges faced by the judiciary in ensuring justice and accountability in cases involving police excesses. The transfer of Sudheer has raised concerns about the potential for interference in the functioning of the courts and the need for greater transparency and accountability in the judicial system.
In recent years, there have been several instances of judges being transferred or facing pressure for their decisions in high-profile cases. The transfer of Sudheer is likely to add to the growing concerns about the independence of the judiciary and the need for greater protection for judges who take tough decisions.
The Sambhal violence case has also highlighted the need for greater accountability and transparency in the functioning of the police. The incident has sparked widespread outrage, and the demand for justice and accountability has been growing. The transfer of Sudheer has raised questions about the commitment of the authorities to ensuring justice and accountability in the case.
As the case proceeds further, it will be important to ensure that the new Chief Judicial Magistrate, Aditya Singh, is able to function independently and without any interference. The judiciary must be able to function without fear or favor, and the transfer of Sudheer must not be seen as a setback to the efforts to ensure justice and accountability in the Sambhal violence case.
In conclusion, the transfer of Sambhal Chief Judicial Magistrate Vibhanshu Sudheer has raised significant concerns about the independence of the judiciary and the potential for interference in the functioning of the courts. The case highlights the challenges faced by the judiciary in ensuring justice and accountability in cases involving police excesses. As the case proceeds further, it will be important to ensure that the judiciary is able to function without fear or favor and that justice is delivered to the victims of the Sambhal violence.
About the Author
