Crocodile tears: Shivraj on Congress’ ‘MGNREGA Bachao’ protest
The Indian political landscape has witnessed a plethora of protests and demonstrations in recent times, with various parties and organizations voicing their concerns on a wide range of issues. One such issue that has gained significant attention is the replacement of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) with the Vidarbha-Bundelkhand-Ram Ganga (VB-G RAM G) Act. The Congress party has been vocal in its opposition to this move, and has even announced plans to launch a nationwide protest, dubbed ‘MGNREGA Bachao’, starting from January 5.
However, Union Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan has dismissed the Congress’s concerns, accusing the party of shedding “crocodile tears” over the issue. According to Chouhan, the Congress’s clamour is purely political, and the party is merely trying to score brownie points by opposing the government’s decision. “This is the same Congress that, from time to time, reduced the budget for MGNREGA,” he said, highlighting the party’s alleged hypocrisy on the issue.
Chouhan’s remarks are not unfounded, as the Congress party’s track record on MGNREGA has been inconsistent, to say the least. While the party has been vocal in its support for the scheme, its actions have often belied its words. The Congress-led UPA government, which was in power from 2004 to 2014, had indeed reduced the budget for MGNREGA on several occasions, despite the scheme’s popularity and effectiveness in providing employment to rural workers.
The MGNREGA scheme, which was launched in 2006, guarantees 100 days of employment to rural workers, and has been widely acclaimed for its role in reducing poverty and promoting rural development. However, the scheme has also been criticized for its implementation, with many alleging that it has been plagued by corruption and inefficiency. The current government’s decision to replace MGNREGA with the VB-G RAM G Act has been seen as an attempt to address these concerns, and to provide a more effective and efficient framework for rural employment.
The VB-G RAM G Act, which is named after three major rivers in India, aims to provide a more comprehensive and integrated approach to rural development, by linking employment guarantees with water conservation and irrigation projects. The Act also provides for the creation of a new agency, which will be responsible for implementing the scheme and ensuring its effective monitoring and evaluation.
While the Congress party has expressed its opposition to the VB-G RAM G Act, citing concerns that it will undermine the guarantees provided by MGNREGA, the government has assured that the new scheme will provide even more benefits to rural workers. According to Chouhan, the VB-G RAM G Act will not only provide employment guarantees, but also help to promote water conservation and irrigation, which are critical for rural development.
The Congress party’s decision to launch the ‘MGNREGA Bachao’ protest has been seen as a political move, aimed at mobilizing public opinion against the government’s decision. However, it remains to be seen whether the party’s efforts will bear fruit, or whether the government’s assurances will convince the public that the new scheme is indeed an improvement over the old one.
As the debate over MGNREGA and the VB-G RAM G Act continues, one thing is clear: the issue of rural employment and development is a critical one, and requires a nuanced and effective approach. While the government’s decision to replace MGNREGA with the VB-G RAM G Act may have its advantages and disadvantages, it is essential that the concerns of all stakeholders, including rural workers and farmers, are taken into account.
In conclusion, the controversy over MGNREGA and the VB-G RAM G Act is a complex one, with both the government and the opposition having valid points to make. While the Congress party’s concerns about the new scheme are understandable, the government’s assurances that it will provide more benefits to rural workers cannot be dismissed outright. As the ‘MGNREGA Bachao’ protest gets underway, it remains to be seen how the issue will unfold, and what the ultimate outcome will be.
About the Author
