Chidambaram Gave Clean Chit to Pak: Shah on ‘Homegrown Terrorist’ Remark
In a recent address to the Lok Sabha, Home Minister Amit Shah ignited a controversy by leveling a serious accusation against former Home Minister and Congress leader, P Chidambaram. Shah claimed that Chidambaram, by questioning the Pakistani identity of the Pahalgam terrorists, was attempting to give a clean chit to Pakistan. This provocative statement has set off a heated debate, with many questioning Shah’s motives and others defending his stance.
The context of Shah’s remark is crucial to understanding the controversy. The Home Minister was addressing the Lok Sabha to brief the nation on Operation Sindoor, a massive crackdown on terrorism in the country. During his speech, Shah highlighted the role of Pakistan-based terrorist organizations in spreading terrorism in India and mentioned the Pahalgam terrorists, who were recently killed in a gunfight with security forces.
Chidambaram, a seasoned politician and former Home Minister, had earlier expressed doubts about the Pakistani identity of the Pahalgam terrorists. He had argued that the lack of concrete evidence to prove their Pakistani origin was a major concern and that the government’s claims seemed exaggerated. Shah, in his response, accused Chidambaram of trying to give a clean chit to Pakistan and attempting to downplay the role of Pakistan-based terrorist organizations in India.
Shah’s claim is based on the fact that two of the slain terrorists had voter numbers recovered from their possession. The Home Minister asserted that this evidence proves beyond a doubt that the terrorists were Pakistani nationals. Many have questioned the relevance of voter numbers as proof of nationality, arguing that it is a simplistic and flawed approach to establishing a person’s nationality. Others have pointed out that even if the voter numbers do belong to Pakistani nationals, it does not necessarily mean that the terrorists were Pakistani.
Chidambaram, in his defense, has maintained that he is not trying to give a clean chit to Pakistan and that his concerns are based on the lack of concrete evidence to prove the Pakistani identity of the terrorists. He has argued that the government’s claims are based on hearsay and unverified intelligence reports and that a thorough investigation is necessary to determine the nationality of the terrorists.
The controversy has sparked a heated debate in the political circles, with many questioning the motives of both the Home Minister and the former Home Minister. Some have accused Shah of using the issue to score political brownie points and to divert attention from the government’s failures in tackling terrorism. Others have defended Shah’s stance, arguing that he is simply highlighting the government’s efforts to combat terrorism and that Chidambaram’s doubts are an attempt to undermine the government’s efforts.
Meanwhile, the opposition has criticized the government for trying to politicize the issue and for using it as a tool to attack the opposition. They have also accused the government of being too quick to jump to conclusions and of ignoring the fact that the investigation into the Pahalgam terrorist attack is still ongoing.
In conclusion, the controversy surrounding Shah’s remark has highlighted the deep divisions in Indian politics. While some have defended Shah’s stance, others have accused him of politicizing the issue and of trying to give a clean chit to Pakistan. The debate has also raised important questions about the government’s approach to tackling terrorism and the need for a thorough and transparent investigation into the Pahalgam terrorist attack.
Source:
https://www.youtube.com/watch
