Gambhir, Gill weren’t happy with Kolkata pitch, had intense chat with curator before Test: Report
The Indian cricket team’s recent Test match against South Africa at the iconic Eden Gardens in Kolkata has been making headlines for all the wrong reasons. The primary focus of attention has been the pitch, which has been criticized by many for being overly spin-friendly and resulting in an unusually high number of wickets falling in a short span of time. According to a recent report, Indian head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Shubman Gill were not pleased with the pitch before the start of the Test match and had a heated conversation with the curator regarding the same.
The report suggests that the Indian team management had specifically requested a “rank turner” – a pitch that favors spin bowling – in order to gain an advantage over the South African team. However, the curator revealed that the team management’s expectations were not entirely met, leading to the intense discussion between Gambhir, Gill, and the curator. The fact that the pitch did not quite live up to the team’s expectations is evident from the fact that 26 wickets fell in just two days of play, with many batsmen struggling to cope with the spin and bounce on offer.
The Eden Gardens pitch has always been known for its unique characteristics, with the soil and climate of the region contributing to its distinctive nature. However, the pitch prepared for this particular Test match seemed to be excessively spin-friendly, with many observers commenting that it was not a fair test of batting skills. The Indian team, which has a rich tradition of producing talented spin bowlers, was expected to benefit from the pitch, but the fact that the South African team was also able to extract significant turn and bounce from the surface suggests that the pitch may have been over-prepared.
The debate surrounding the pitch has sparked a wider discussion about the role of curators in preparing pitches for international matches. While it is understandable that teams may want to prepare pitches that favor their strengths, it is equally important to ensure that the pitch is fair and balanced, allowing for a competitive contest between bat and ball. The fact that the Indian team management specifically requested a rank turner raises questions about the ethics of pitch preparation and whether teams should be allowed to dictate the nature of the pitch to such an extent.
The pitch curator, who has been at the center of the controversy, has defended his preparation, stating that he was simply following the instructions of the Indian team management. However, the fact that the pitch has been widely criticized suggests that there may be some merit to the argument that the pitch was over-prepared. The curator’s comments also highlight the challenges faced by pitch curators, who must balance the demands of the teams with the need to prepare a fair and balanced pitch.
The incident has also raised questions about the leadership of the Indian team, with some observers suggesting that Gambhir and Gill may have been overly aggressive in their approach to pitch preparation. While it is understandable that teams may want to gain every advantage possible, it is equally important to ensure that the spirit of the game is upheld and that the pitch is prepared in a fair and balanced manner.
In conclusion, the controversy surrounding the Kolkata pitch has highlighted the challenges and complexities of pitch preparation in international cricket. While teams may want to prepare pitches that favor their strengths, it is equally important to ensure that the pitch is fair and balanced, allowing for a competitive contest between bat and ball. The incident has also raised questions about the leadership of the Indian team and the role of curators in preparing pitches for international matches. As the debate continues, one thing is clear – the pitch at Eden Gardens will remain a topic of discussion for a long time to come.
About the Author
